Fix wrong gains

This commit is contained in:
jfmcarreira committed 2018-12-04 02:43:35 +00:00
1 parent 773b501882
commit bb99815d8f
1 file changed
+2 -2
@@ -436,13 +436,13 @@ Table~\ref{Table6:AverageGains} shows the average quality gains in comparison wi
These were obtained with the proposed scheme and the four different techniques used in selection method, i.e., methods used in the streams \SMEC to \SMEXPELTWEN. These were obtained with the proposed scheme and the four different techniques used in selection method, i.e., methods used in the streams \SMEC to \SMEXPELTWEN.
The average quality gains are measured across all test cases, i.e., test set with different bitrates and different packet loss ratios. The average quality gains are measured across all test cases, i.e., test set with different bitrates and different packet loss ratios.
Results in Table~\ref{Table6:AverageGains} show that the robust coded streams \SMEC to \SMEXPELTWEN are able to achieve acceptable average quality gains up to 1.50 dB (see results for \SMEXPELTEN). Results in Table~\ref{Table6:AverageGains} show that the robust coded streams \SMEC to \SMEXPELTWEN are able to achieve acceptable average quality gains up to 1.52 dB (see results for \SMEXPELTEN).
However, since the implementation of robust coding techniques decreases the coding efficiency, it also leads to lower quality than the reference \ac{hevc}. However, since the implementation of robust coding techniques decreases the coding efficiency, it also leads to lower quality than the reference \ac{hevc}.
This is noticeable in the results obtained for the Four People sequence in the streams \SMEXP to \SMEXPELTWEN and for the Kristen and Sara sequence in the streams \SMEXPELTEN and \SMEXPELTWEN (see red ellipses). This is noticeable in the results obtained for the Four People sequence in the streams \SMEXP to \SMEXPELTWEN and for the Kristen and Sara sequence in the streams \SMEXPELTEN and \SMEXPELTWEN (see red ellipses).
The overall performance of such methods reveals that they are not the best options for transmission conditions with low \acs{plr} (higher number of conditions have \acs{plr} lower than 3\%). The overall performance of such methods reveals that they are not the best options for transmission conditions with low \acs{plr} (higher number of conditions have \acs{plr} lower than 3\%).
On the contrary, the proposed method is always capable of outperforming the reference \ac{hevc} and achieve quality gains from 0.28 dB to 3.28 dB. On the contrary, the proposed method is always capable of outperforming the reference \ac{hevc} and achieve quality gains from 0.28 dB to 3.28 dB.
For the Kimono and Tennis sequences, it is able to achieve the highest quality gains, of up 3.07 dB and 3.28 dB, respectively (see blue ellipses). For the Kimono and Tennis sequences, it is able to achieve the highest quality gains, of up 3.07 dB and 3.28 dB, respectively (see blue ellipses).
Summarising, by adaptively selecting the video stream, and implicitly the robust coding technique, the proposed method is able to achieve a better trade-off between coding efficiency and error robustness, achieving an average quality gain across different bitrates and \acs{plr} of 1.88 dB. Summarising, by adaptively selecting the video stream, and implicitly the robust coding technique, the proposed method is able to achieve a better trade-off between coding efficiency and error robustness, achieving an average quality gain across different bitrates and \acs{plr} of 1.69 dB.
Finally, the performance of the proposed method is evaluated for video sequences, which was not fed into the \ac{nn} training phase. Finally, the performance of the proposed method is evaluated for video sequences, which was not fed into the \ac{nn} training phase.
This study aims at finding the accuracy of the optimal stream selection in case of a new video content. This study aims at finding the accuracy of the optimal stream selection in case of a new video content.